Halloween Peanut Butter Cookie Cups Recipe

If you’re looking for a cookie recipe that’s as fun to make as it is to eat, then you’re in the right place. This Halloween Peanut Butter Cookie Cups Recipe is one of my all-time favorites to bake around spooky season. It’s a simple peanut butter cookie base transformed into adorable and slightly creepy little treats topped with candy eyes, chocolate drizzles, and marshmallow magic. Trust me, once you try these little cuties, you’ll want to keep making them year after year. Let me walk you through everything you need to know to nail this perfect Halloween dessert!

this …

Ingredients & Why They Work

Every ingredient in this Halloween Peanut Butter Cookie Cups Recipe plays a role in building flavor and texture – plus, the candy toppings bring in that extra fun factor that turns ordinary cookies into festive treats. Here’s a quick rundown and some tips before you shop.

• Creamy Peanut Butter: Use a smooth, high-quality peanut butter for the best texture; natural varieties with no excess oil work great.
• Granulated Sugar: This adds sweetness and helps create that slight crispness on the cookie edges.
• Egg: Acts as a binder to hold everything together while keeping the cookies soft.
• White Chocolate Reese’s Cups: Perfect for mummy and eyeball designs – their creamy filling melts just right on warm cookies.
• Candy Eyes: These are essential for the spooky look and can be found in most baking aisles or online.
• Ghirardelli White & Dark Chocolate Melting Wafers: These melt smoothly for drizzling and decorating without seizing.
• Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Miniatures: Great for spider cookies, their size fits beautifully on cookie cups.
• Marshmallows (optional): Can be used as an alternative for some designs and add a fluffy texture twist.
• Sparkly Red Gel: For that creepy bloody eyeball effect – makes your cookies stand out at any Halloween party.

Make It Your Way

One of the reasons I adore this Halloween Peanut Butter Cookie Cups Recipe is how flexible it is. I often tweak the toppings based on what I have on hand or the vibe of my Halloween party. You can totally make it your own and have fun experimenting.

• Variation: Last year, I swapped the candy eyes for mini chocolate chips and used pretzel sticks to create spider legs – it was a hit and gave a salty-sweet twist!
• Dietary swap: You can easily make this gluten-free by checking your peanut butter and candy ingredients, or try almond butter for a slightly different flavor.
• Seasonal twist: Add a sprinkle of pumpkin spice to the cookie dough for an autumnal flair that smells heavenly baking.
• Extra spooky: Use edible googly eyes or glow-in-the-dark sprinkles if you’re baking with kids who love everything animated.

Step-by-Step: How I Make Halloween Peanut Butter Cookie Cups Recipe

Step 1: Mixing Your Cookie Magic

Start by preheating your oven to 350°F and spraying your mini muffin tin with baking spray. In a medium bowl, mix creamy peanut butter, sugar, and a large egg until the texture is smooth and fully combined. This simple dough is your canvas, so no need for elaborate creaming or chilling – just stir it until it’s uniform.

Step 2: Scooping & Baking

Use a 1-tablespoon cookie scoop or spoon to drop dollops of cookie dough into the mini muffin pan, filling each cup. Pop the tray in the oven and bake for 12 to 14 minutes until cookies turn golden but still soft. This timing is key – too long, and they’ll dry out; too short, and they won’t hold their shape.

Step 3: Pressing & Decorating Immediately

This is where the Halloween magic really starts! Right when the cookies come out of the oven, gently press your chosen Reese’s cups or marshmallow halves into each cookie. Don’t wait—cookies need to be hot so that candy melts into them slightly, creating a snug fit. Then grab your melted chocolates, candy eyes, and gels to bring your mummies, spiders, and spooky eyeballs to life.

How to Serve Halloween Peanut Butter Cookie Cups Recipe

Garnishes

I love using extra candy eyes on top for maximum spooky appeal, plus a drizzle of white or dark chocolate as “mummy wraps” or “spider legs.” Occasionally, I add edible glitter or colored sugar sprinkles to bring a whimsical shine that kids adore. The red gel is my go-to for the bloody eyeballs – it looks dramatic and delicious!

Side Dishes

These cookie cups pair beautifully with a chilled glass of milk (classic, right?). For a party, I usually line them up with pumpkin-shaped sugar cookies or a festive fruit platter like black grapes and orange slices for a nice contrast. They also balance well with a warm cup of spiced apple cider or hot chocolate.

Creative Ways to Present

One year, I set these out inside a carved pumpkin “bowl” lined with parchment – total showstopper. Another fun trick is arranging your Halloween Peanut Butter Cookie Cups Recipe on a serving tray decorated with faux spider webs and plastic spiders, turning your dessert table into a spooky scene. Individually placing each cookie cup in mini cupcake liners also makes for an easy grab-and-go option at parties.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

I like to store leftover cookie cups in an airtight container at room temperature. They keep well for up to 3 days, but honestly, I’ve rarely had them last that long! Just be gentle when stacking to avoid disturbing the delicate decorations.

Freezing

Freezing works too! I freeze these in a single layer on a baking sheet first, then transfer them to a freezer bag to protect the decorations. When I’m ready to enjoy, I let them thaw in the fridge overnight to prevent condensation from making the candy soggy.

Reheating

If you want a warm cookie cup, I reheat them gently in a low oven (about 275°F for 5-7 minutes), watching carefully so the chocolate doesn’t melt too much. Microwaving can make the peanut butter filling a bit oily, so oven reheating is my preferred method.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

Honestly, this Halloween Peanut Butter Cookie Cups Recipe is one I keep coming back to because it’s just so joyful to make and share. I love how it combines simplicity with that festive flair that gets everyone excited during the spooky season. You don’t have to be an expert baker to pull these off, and they bring such smiles to faces (those candy eyes work wonders!). So grab your mixing bowl, clear a little space in your kitchen, and dive into these delightful treats. You’ll be glad you did!

Print