Bloody Eyeball Cupcakes Recipe

If you’re looking to wow your friends and family with a dessert that’s as spooky as it is delicious, you’ve hit the jackpot. This Bloody Eyeball Cupcakes Recipe is one of my all-time favorites for Halloween parties or just to add a fun, creepy touch to any gathering. It’s not just about the eerie eyeball decoration—the cake is moist, the cream cheese frosting dreamy, and the cherry “blood” filling gives it a juicy surprise that really brings these cupcakes to life. Trust me, once you try them, you’ll want to make these every year!

this …

Ingredients & Why They Work

This Bloody Eyeball Cupcakes Recipe uses simple, easy-to-find ingredients that combine to give you that spooky vibe with amazing flavor and texture. Each one plays an important role—not just for taste but for creating the visual “wow” factor that makes this recipe a crowd-pleaser.

• Red velvet cake mix: Offers that classic cocoa flavor and vibrant red color that sets the perfect spooky base.
• Cheesecake instant pudding mix: Adds moisture and richness to the cake batter, making sure your cupcakes stay tender.
• Cherry pie filling: Acts as the “blood” in the eyeball, giving surprise bursts of sweet-tart cherry inside the cupcake.
• Cream cheese: The heart of the frosting, providing tang and creaminess that balances the sweet cake and cherries.
• Butter: Softens the frosting and adds smooth richness.
• Vanilla extract: Enhances the overall flavor without overpowering the other components.
• Cream or milk: Helps achieve the perfect frosting consistency for piping.
• Powdered sugar: Sweetens and thickens the frosting into that classic creamy texture.
• Red sparkle food gel: Creates those realistic blood squiggles that make these cupcakes look seriously creepy.
• Eyeball gumballs (or eyeball candies): The pièce de résistance—a fun and spooky edible eyeball topper that seals the deal.

Make It Your Way

What I love most about the Bloody Eyeball Cupcakes Recipe is how easy it is to customize. Whether you want to dial up the spooky factor, adjust for dietary needs, or simply tweak flavors, you can make this recipe your own and nail it every time.

• Variation: For a deeper “eyeball” look, I sometimes swap cherry pie filling for strawberry preserves for a slightly less sweet, more natural jam texture—still delicious with the cream cheese frosting.
• Dietary modifications: If you’re gluten-free, try a gluten-free red velvet cake mix and be sure to check the pudding mix ingredients—this recipe adapts nicely.
• Kids-Friendly: Swap out the eyeball gumballs for small white chocolate discs and use edible markers to draw eyeballs—they’ll love helping you decorate.

Step-by-Step: How I Make Bloody Eyeball Cupcakes Recipe

Step 1: Mix the Batter and Bake

Start by preheating your oven to 350°F, and line two muffin tins with about 16 cupcake liners. I prefer these sturdy liners because they help the cupcakes hold their shape after coring. In a large bowl, prepare the red velvet cake mix according to the package directions—I like to whisk it just until smooth to avoid overmixing. Then, stir in the cheesecake instant pudding mix. This little addition makes the cupcakes extra moist and gives a subtle richness that’s so good.

Divide the batter evenly among the liners, filling them about three-quarters full. Bake for 15 to 18 minutes—mine usually hit the sweet spot right at 17 minutes. To check doneness, I insert a toothpick near the center; you want it clean or with just a few moist crumbs sticking. Let them cool completely before moving on, especially because you’ll be coring next.

Step 2: Core and Fill with Cherry “Blood”

Now for the fun part: removing the cupcake centers to create room for your cherry pie filling “blood.” I use a small paring knife, carefully inserting it into the cupcake and gently twisting out a neat core—don’t dig too deep or you’ll risk breaking through the bottom. Toss the leftover cake pieces or save them for a quick snack (I’m guilty of this every time!).

With a small spoon, gently fill each cavity with cherry pie filling. I recommend tucking in at least two cherries into each—you want that juicy pop when you bite into it! This touch elevates the cupcake from just spooky to downright unforgettable.

Step 3: Whip Up the Cream Cheese Frosting

In the bowl of a stand mixer, beat together the softened cream cheese, butter, vanilla extract, and cream (or milk) using the paddle attachment. It usually takes me about 1-2 minutes to get everything silky and creamy—don’t rush this step! Gradually add the powdered sugar, about a cup at a time, beating until the frosting is fluffy and light.

Once your frosting is ready, transfer it to a piping bag fitted with a large open-circle tip. This tip makes it easy to pipe tall, swirly mounds that fully cover the cherry filling and the cupcake hole for a clean finish. Don’t be shy—go for a good height. It makes the eyeball effect really pop!

Step 4: Decorate and Add the Creepy Eyeball

Using your red sparkle food gel, draw squiggly “blood veins” running up and down the sides of each frosted cupcake. I love that this gives each cupcake a unique, slightly gory look without any extra effort. The perfect finishing touch? Plop an eyeball gumball on top—make sure it’s centered right on the peak of the frosting. Seeing those eerily realistic eyeballs staring back at me always makes me smile before the first bite.

Serve these cupcakes at your next Halloween bash and watch people’s faces light up (or squirm) in delight!

How to Serve Bloody Eyeball Cupcakes Recipe

Garnishes

I keep garnishes simple but effective—red sparkle gel veins and eyeball gumballs are my go-tos, but you could also scatter some edible glitter or red sanding sugar on the frosting for extra shimmer. For a more dramatic effect, a small drizzle of raspberry or strawberry sauce around the cupcake base looks like dripping blood and amps up the spooky factor.

Side Dishes

These cupcakes hold center stage, but I like serving them alongside light finger foods like veggie sticks with ranch dip or a simple cheese platter to balance out the sweetness. For Halloween parties, you could pair them with “witches’ brew” punch or a tangy cranberry cocktail—both complement the cherry “blood” flavor perfectly.

Creative Ways to Present

Try arranging the cupcakes on a black cake stand layered with faux cobwebs or scatter plastic spiders around them for a creepier display. I once used clear plastic “test tubes” filled with fake blood jelly alongside the cupcakes for guests to “dip” their eyeballs—such a hit! You can also place them on a platter lined with red-tinted tissue paper to enhance the bloody vibe.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

After a party, I always store leftover Bloody Eyeball Cupcakes in an airtight container in the fridge. Because of the cream cheese frosting and cherry filling, refrigeration is a must to keep everything fresh and safe. They’ll keep well for up to 3 days, though honestly, they rarely last that long at my house!

Freezing

You can freeze these cupcakes before frosting and filling. I bake and cool them fully, then wrap each cupcake tightly in plastic wrap and place them in a freezer-safe container. When you’re ready, thaw overnight in the fridge, then core, fill, frost, and decorate. I’ve found freezing after decorating can be tricky because the frosting and gel don’t always thaw well.

Reheating

Since these cupcakes are best served chilled due to the frosting and cherry filling, I don’t recommend reheating once frosted. If you want to warm them slightly, remove the topping and heat the cupcake alone briefly in the microwave, then add fresh frosting and filling afterward for best results.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

Making these Bloody Eyeball Cupcakes Recipe always feels like a little kitchen magic to me. There’s such joy in transforming simple cupcakes into a spooky, delicious treat that’s sure to impress and delight. Whether it’s a Halloween party, themed event, or just a fun weekend project, you’ll find yourself coming back to this recipe time and again. So grab your piping bag, some eyeballs, and dive in—you’re going to LOVE the creepy, creamy, cherry-filled surprise in each bite!

Print